Having watched TNG without being influenced by the community. I agree that his character starts pretty obnoxious, but I always got the sense that the point of his character was that his inclusion on the ship as a kid raised by this future world was just as “alien” as Data or Worf. Then again, it was also obvious that he occasionally got completely brain bonked for some episodes in order to make him the naive child of the group.
I see it this way too now. “What does this culture do with this situation?” - and all jokes aside, pretty good chance some of the answers to that snuck in subliminally, that influences how I parent. Haven’t watched too much in 20+ years, but it’s there.
But yeah nonetheless, I do understand the annoyance folks have with the lad.
That’s an excellent question. I wonder if it has something to do with your age when you first saw the series, or maybe the problem that adult writers tend to not write kids very well. I bet at least part of it is that Picard himself treats Wesley pretty poorly in several episodes. Oh, and the fact that he solves the problem of the week ludicrously easily a couple of times, in a Gary Stu sort of way.
Wesley was a Mary Sue. The writers of Star Trek should’ve been able to avoid that trope given the original Mary Sue was a character in a Star Trek fanfic.
Why the hell is a kid at the helm Starship? Apparently because “he’s a genius”. Someone piloting an airliner has to have many many hours of experiencing before they’re allowed to do that, but apparently in the future you just have to be a smart kid, experience doesn’t matter?
And yeah he solves the problems adults can’t figure out. It’s this weird thing where writers think they need a kid in something so kids will like it. And even better yet, a kid that’s smarter than the adults! It winds up just annoying everyone.
What’s with the hate Wesley gets? I didn’t find his character to be detestable. At least not as much as the ferengi ds9 kid.
Nog makes Wesley look like fucking’… Shaft!
Both Wesley and Nog started out with rough writing. Once their characters build out, they improve. Nog moreso, being part of a serialized show.
Having watched TNG without being influenced by the community. I agree that his character starts pretty obnoxious, but I always got the sense that the point of his character was that his inclusion on the ship as a kid raised by this future world was just as “alien” as Data or Worf. Then again, it was also obvious that he occasionally got completely brain bonked for some episodes in order to make him the naive child of the group.
I see it this way too now. “What does this culture do with this situation?” - and all jokes aside, pretty good chance some of the answers to that snuck in subliminally, that influences how I parent. Haven’t watched too much in 20+ years, but it’s there.
But yeah nonetheless, I do understand the annoyance folks have with the lad.
That’s an excellent question. I wonder if it has something to do with your age when you first saw the series, or maybe the problem that adult writers tend to not write kids very well. I bet at least part of it is that Picard himself treats Wesley pretty poorly in several episodes. Oh, and the fact that he solves the problem of the week ludicrously easily a couple of times, in a Gary Stu sort of way.
Wesley was a Mary Sue. The writers of Star Trek should’ve been able to avoid that trope given the original Mary Sue was a character in a Star Trek fanfic.
Why the hell is a kid at the helm Starship? Apparently because “he’s a genius”. Someone piloting an airliner has to have many many hours of experiencing before they’re allowed to do that, but apparently in the future you just have to be a smart kid, experience doesn’t matter?
And yeah he solves the problems adults can’t figure out. It’s this weird thing where writers think they need a kid in something so kids will like it. And even better yet, a kid that’s smarter than the adults! It winds up just annoying everyone.
Tbf, there are is lot’s of space in space to practice driving gnihihi. I’ll show myself out