That’s a fair point. America has always been this way since its inception

No, that’s not what they’re saying. They’re saying that America is not a nation at all. The material basis of American “nationhood” is liberal capitalism and settler colonialism. American language, culture, and national identity did not develop organically but instead was invented to legitimise the project. The solution to these people would be to abolish America entirely

how about America (and by extension the American police state) as a whole just ceases to exist