Is the OP not obvious sarcasm? In what world is packing boxes skilled labour when flipping burgers isn’t?
I don’t think it’s too unusual for people to think of their own jobs as super important and complicated and everything else is just simple shit in comparison. Watching someone do something they are trained at (because they do it day-in-day-out) often looks simple … until the moment you try it yourself and realize the amount of concentration you suddenly need and the many questions that pop up for details you didn’t even notice before.
It’s a form of short-sightedness and/or lack of experience. But not uncommon.
It might be a side effect that we are all well of aware of the smallest of details and hidden complexity of what we do as a job/serious-hobby, whilst having a very high level and ultra shallow idea of everything else, hence tending to think about other people’s job that “I could easilly learn do that”.
I’ve learned a number of expert areas over the years in my career and it’s always that which happens for me: I start with the idea that “it should be easy” and about 2 years later I’m keenly aware on just how little I still know about it. Even after being aware of this effect, I still start by significiantly underestimating the true complexity of any new area I’m learning.
It’s the same “underestimating of the complexity of what we don’t know in depth” that’s behind the Dunning-Krugger Effect IMHO.
Op is high. Both are entry level jobs. Nothing skilled about it.
There’s no such thing as unskilled labour.
I think it’s a straightforward categorization. If it’s a skill you could pick up as a toddler or young child (packing a box and matching shapes, flipping things, moving things around, bagging things) and doesn’t require further education or training (as in, literally anyone you meet on the street could do it), or something extremely simple to automate away with a script, I think it’s reasonable to call it unskilled.
The term was pushes by the owners to justify low pay. A toddler can’t be a fry cook or work in a packing center. Is someone who’s done it for a year likely to be better at it then someone who started yesterday? Then fuck off with this working class division bullshit.
I didn’t mention fry cooks or anything of that nature. I think I was pretty clear with my criteria of what I consider unskilled.
For example, I wouldn’t call grocery bagging or cart collecting “skilled labor” in any way. And there are people working at stores who exclusively do those jobs.
Packing center… depends on what the role entails, I suppose. If you’re just packing boxes and taping them shut to prep for shipping, I don’t think I’d consider that a skill. Especially considering the state of most packages I receive from Amazon.
Especially considering the state of most packages I receive from Amazon.
In other words it’s a job that could be done better… Maybe the people doing it could be more skilled.
You’re barfing up the absolute bullshit that’s used to justify not paying people enough to survive, and to keep people who work for a living at each others’ throats. Stop trying to find the thin dividing line that makes you superior to someone who works hard all day putting things in boxes.
Stop trying to find the thin dividing line that makes you superior to someone who works hard all day putting things in boxes.
I’ve spent over 15 years in IT building my skill set, moving into virtualization and automation, and still continue learning new things and becoming certified for new skills every few years.
I won’t apologize for thinking my skill set is more valuable than that of putting things in boxes.
It’s not an idea of superiority, as you put it, and more just a focus on personal growth and effort to continue educating myself and learning new things independently of any school, university, or job training.
I’ve done physical labor, worked groundskeeping, retail, food services, etc. in the past. Many roles of that nature have a low skill ceiling and are eventually dead ends unless you can somehow transfer to a role in management or other leadership position that would be transferable for more pay and training opportunities.
“Skilled labor” lmao.
Beat me to it, that’s like saying my washing dishes and talking to old people for a living is skilled labor
I mean, isn’t it? There’s a reason we have TV shows where we record the CEO fucking up doing the “least skilled” jobs in their organization. It’s easy to film because there’s always another dumbass CEO who doesn’t know what they’re in for.
I work a job where I get to interact with everyone else’s jobs, and I haven’t run into a single one that I could confidently call “unskilled”.
Also, “skilled labour”?
Amazon treat warehouse staff like shit specifically because you ain’t. You will be replaced in a second.
Minimum wage is what most people will be on unless they’ve got something to offer other than desperation to survive.
All these people deserve to make more money.
AND, at the same time
Packing boxes is not skilled labor. It’s not like that shit requires two years of trade school.
Packing a box is skilled labor?
No, that’s why temping agencies easily fill warehouse positions
All labour is skilled labor. Unskilled labour was created by capitalists as a flimsy justification for paying people unlivable wages. ANY labour deserves a livable wage. Needing a second job is an injustice.
Now that being said, packing boxes for Amazon is 100% unskilled labour. A machine spits out the box template sheet with creases where the cardboard sheet should be folded to turn it into a box within seconds. Another machine prints the receipt that goes inside, and Another machine spits out an appropriate amount of packing to make sure the product stays in place inside the box. Another machine spits out a calculated amount of tape. Another machine spits out the info sticker that needs to be stuck on the outside. Does this need a lot of skill or training? I don’t think so, no.
Technically neither are since they don’t require a recognised qualification to be eligible to apply.
I mean… Just as logically though, they both are… Any shit takes practice to get good at really.
deleted by creator
McDonald’s definitely don’t care if their employees are effective or not. And they don’t reward effectiveness so what’s the point in trying.
If McDonalds didn’t care about effectiveness they wouldn’t be a household name, let alone an international corporation. People talk down about fast food, but it isn’t their business strategies that are bad.
I think the problem is that people don’t get paid enough to care anymore. Not even the managers. There’s too much wealth hoarding at the top in the US.
That’s not what the term means though. These are actual, real terms, that denote the amount of qualification needed to do a job.
Does packing boxes really count as skilled labor? I would have assumed it would be unskilled labor just like the burger flipper.
As a former warehouse worker and shipping clerk, it is 100% unskilled labor. We would sometimes hire temp workers for really busy periods, and it would take about 30 minutes to train them.
Yeah, and as someone who works in QA for a carrier repacking some of those boxes I can tell. Shippers really don’t seem to care that their packages don’t even make it to the shipping phase, let alone through our damn building.
Listen bud. Labor is labor. All of it takes some skill. You still had to “train” or teach a skill to the one performing the labor.
That’s the big lie the right wants you to believe; there’s no such thing as unskilled labor. You have to learn every job you start. Flipping burgers, packing boxes, cleaning, washing dishes, etc all have a learning curve. There is no job you can walk in off the street and start doing without previous knowledge.
fridge temp iq labourer.
This is an example of how capitalists have spent decades manipulating people into thinking their enemy was anyone else except the capitalists.
skilled labor is capitalist propaganda to keep wages low
The reply to that tweet makes a lot of sense and it’s been around for a while. Why doesn’t this change more people’s minds? It changed mine the first time I saw it.
The burgers at McDonalds are flipped by a machine now I thought? They may have replaced those workers?
I think they replaced half the cashiers here, but not at every branch. Do you have machine cooks at your McD?
